Logic Pro X vs GarageBand which is better? ( compared).Logic Pro vs. Garageband: do I really need to upgrade? | MusicRadar
Looking for:
7 Reasons Why You Should Upgrade From GarageBand To Logic Pro X : - Logic Pro X vs GarageBand: What’s in the box? |
Logic Pro X vs GarageBand: Which Mac music-production software is best? | Macworld
- Logic pro x vs garageband 11 free
This is a substantial difference, in more than just sheer volume. Many of the loops belong to specific sets, say 70s Electric Piano, and fit together seamlessly to create varied patterns. With Logic these sets are complete, but the GarageBand selection omits large chunks, making it harder to assemble more complex tracks. As an example 70s Electric piano has twenty nine different variations in Logic, whereas there are only two on GarageBand. Read next: Best free GarageBand for Mac plugins.
These are very powerful additions that allow you to craft tones with precision. Also included is a musical score feature which can automatically turn your creations into full notation for those scary people who can actually read music. You know, keyboard players. One feature both programs now share is Drummer. Logic does have the additional ability to build custom kits, thanks to its Drum Kit Designer, but the range of styles available already will be enough for most people.
Guitarists are well catered for, with both apps offering twenty five guitar and Bass amps, plus thirty five different effect pedals. These all sound great and are easy to adjust thanks to the graphical representations of dials and switches that adorn the real thing. There are also tutorials available where stars such as Sting and Norah Jones teach you how to play a few of their songs.
The first thing you notice when opening both apps is that they look practically identical. This is a deliberate choice from Apple, positioning GarageBand as a kind of training ground for would-be musicians who can then upgrade to Logic without having to learn an entirely new way of working. The similarities are not just confined to the cosmetics. GarageBand and Logic share a common code base, meaning that any projects you create in the former can then be taken with you into the latter without any problems.
The main work area features a timeline where recordings are displayed on their relevant tracks, plus a few different panes that house the available instruments, effects, editing functions, and loop library.
These can be opened and closed by the various icons at the top of the screen. Logic starts with a few more of these, including the Inspector, which opens a dedicated Channel Strip for the selected track. Logic also has the option of a full mixer panel that displays all of the Channel strips in the project — very useful for more advanced compositions — all of which can be controlled by a range of external MIDI mixing boards. Both programs are designed to be single window operations, eschewing the confusion that can result from various panels being buried beneath others.
Also included is a musical rating characteristic which might mechanically flip your creations into full notation for these scary individuals who can really learn music. You know, keyboard gamers. One characteristic each applications now share is Drummer. Logic does have the extra potential to construct customized kits, because of its Drum Kit Designer, however the vary of types out there already will likely be sufficient for most individuals. Guitarists are effectively catered for, with each apps providing twenty 5 guitar and Bass amps, plus thirty 5 completely different impact pedals.
These all sound nice and are straightforward to regulate because of the graphical representations of dials and switches that adorn the true factor. There are additionally tutorials out there the place stars akin to Sting and Norah Jones train you find out how to play a couple of of their songs. The very first thing you discover when opening each apps is that they appear virtually equivalent.
This is a deliberate selection from Apple, positioning GarageBand as a type of coaching floor for would-be musicians who can then improve to Logic with out having to be taught a completely new manner of working. GarageBand and Logic share a standard code base, which means that any tasks you create within the former can then be taken with you into the latter with none issues.
Again, this enables the person to dabble and experiment with the free software program within the information that they will not have to start once more in the event that they improve.
The principal work space incorporates a timeline the place recordings are displayed on their related tracks, plus a couple of completely different panes that home the out there devices, results, enhancing features, and loop library.
These may be opened and closed by the assorted icons on the high of the display. Logic begins with a couple of extra of those, together with the Inspector, which opens a devoted Channel Strip for the chosen monitor.
From right here you possibly can add results, EQ models, and determine find out how to route the sign — one thing that is not attainable on GarageBand. Logic additionally has the choice of a full mixer panel that shows all the Channel strips within the challenge — very helpful for extra superior compositions — all of which may be managed by a variety of exterior MIDI mixing boards. Both applications are designed to be single window operations, eschewing the confusion that may outcome from numerous panels being buried beneath others.
If you need one thing open simply click on on it, in any other case it might probably disappear. For these with a number of display shows Logic does have the choice to creates Spaces fashion home windows so you possibly can have set options open on completely different ones — say a full display matrix editor.
Graphically the format is clear, sensible, and straightforward to work with. Tracks are color coded and have icons of their instrument sort so you possibly can rapidly discern between them.
Each instrument additionally has Smart Controls, which once more seem like the knobs, dials, and sliders you may discover on the true issues. With these you possibly can rapidly alter tones to get issues nearer to your most well-liked fashion, and in case you hyperlink it to your iPad then they really flip and slide, making it even simpler to manage. Logic Pro X model This means you possibly can navigate your challenge extra simply utilizing the miniature timeline displayed within the Touch Bar.
Namely, that the complexity is all there, you simply want to show it on. In the preferences menu there may be an possibility for Show Advanced Tools, clicking this adjustments issues in an enormous manner.
Here you will discover choices for a number of layers of depth in several areas of this system akin to MIDI management, Control surfaces, and Advanced enhancing. GarageBand has easy and usable edit controls — simply slide the monitor quantity up or down, Pan the sign left or proper, and manually automate fade ins and outs on the timeline.
It additionally has the flexibility to appropriate timing points with Flex Time, a intelligent characteristic for errant gamers that allows you to stretch the recording in order that off-beat notes come into line with appropriately performed ones.
But for some of us, that desire to spend time making music tips over into something more fundamental, where we find ourselves butting up against the limitations of a piece of software, no matter how far down the road they have allowed us to travel. Simply put, we want more - more control, more sophistication and more tools to manage the marginal gains which come when we want to turn a really good feature set into an excellent one.
Similarly, whilst you can draw Automation lines to manage the dynamic contours of assorted parameters, there are limitations over how this can be done. But the first time you press Play on your formerly-GarageBand-now-Logic Pro X project, it will sound just the same as where you left it. Put simply, Logic Pro X is there to take your workflow and production on to the next level.
Jono Buchanan.
Comments
Post a Comment